What to postNo. 34

How to Tell Your Own Story in a Post Without Oversharing

Tell one moment, what it felt like, what changed, and where you are now. Share things you've come through, and keep what you're still in the middle of for people who know you. Before you post, ask if it's yours to tell and who might read it.

By Martha Krejci · 4 min read ·

Your story is the reason people will trust you. It's also the thing you're most nervous to post.

You can tell it without putting your whole life on the internet. There's a way to be real and still keep what's private, private.

Here's the shape of a good story post, and three questions to ask before you hit share.

Why your story matters at all

Anyone can post a tip. Only you can post what happened to you.

"That's me" is what gets her to comment, follow, and one day ask what you'd recommend.

The shape of a story post

  1. The moment.

    One scene. Where you were, what happened. "I was standing in the school parking lot when the email came in."

  2. What it felt like.

    One honest sentence. Skip the summary and say the feeling.

  3. What changed.

    What you decided, tried or finally understood.

  4. Where you are now.

    One line. Then hand it to her with a question.

Four parts, maybe ten sentences. And start with the moment. Here's how to write a first line that stops the scroll.

Share scars. Keep open wounds private.

This is the best rule I know for what to share.

A scar

Something you've been through and come out the other side of. You can tell it without falling apart.

An open wound

Something you're still in the middle of. It needs a friend or a counselor before it needs an audience.

The test

Can you read the comments, kind or unkind, and be okay? If yes, it's a scar.

The wound will be a scar someday. It'll make a better post then, too.

Three questions before you post

Details to keep, details to cut

Keep the small, human ones. The parking lot. The cold coffee. What you said out loud to nobody.

Cut the ones that could hurt someone or find you:

You can say "someone close to me" and the story still works.

When your story includes a product

Sometimes the thing that changed was something you started using. That's a real story and you can tell it.

The full how-to is in how to share a product without feeling salesy.

I trained My Checklist to do this

Tell My Checklist what really happened this week (the birthday, the flat tire, the thing that made you laugh) and your real life shows up in your posts. It writes from what you tell it.

If you freeze up

Talk it out first. Open your voice notes and tell the story the way you'd tell a friend in the car.

Then hand that to Claude and ask it to tidy it into the four parts without changing your words. Here's how to keep it sounding like you.

And if you're sure nothing in your life is worth a story, read this one first.

Quick answers

How personal should my posts be?

Personal enough that she sees herself, and settled enough that you can read the comments without it hurting.

Can I post about my family?

Ask them first, and tell your part of the story. Leave out anything they'd be embarrassed by later.

What if someone leaves a mean comment on my story?

Hide it, and block them if you need to. It's your profile. You don't have to host unkindness.

Do I have to share hard things at all?

No. Small, everyday stories build just as much trust. The pantry counts.

Your 30 minutes today

  • Pick one small story that's a scar.
  • Write it in the four parts.
  • Run the three questions, then post it or save it for tomorrow.
&

Want your real stories shaped into posts for you, in your own words?

My Checklist writes your week.

Your posts. Your emails. In your voice, in one list. You open it, check the boxes, and go live your life.

7-day free trial. Cancel anytime.

Keep going

Martha Krejci

Who wrote this

Martha Krejci spent five years in leadership at GoDaddy, supporting small business owners. She has worked from home with her family since 2016, and she teaches women to get paid to post in 30 minutes a day.